Document Details

Exploration of Tolerable Risk Guidelines for the USACE Levee Safety Program

U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) | January 10th, 2011


Risk assessment methodologies have been used around the world to provide decision makers with information on the likelihood of adverse outcomes and resulting consequences. Governments are recently moving to broader flood risk management approaches that encompass structural measures and manage floodplain development while recognizing climate change, environmental functions and social factors. Such flood risk approaches consider the probability of a flood hazard occurring; the vulnerability of flood mitigation measures implemented to lessen flood consequences through preparation, response, recovery and mitigation; and the consequences that result from the mitigated flood event.

Within that overarching flood risk management context, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers (USACE) is considering risk management approaches for dams and levee systems in order to make better decisions, better prioritize and justify risk reduction measures, better communicate risks to decision makers and the public, and better understand and evaluate public safety risks in an environment of shared flood risk management responsibilities.

USACE consideration of risk management approaches includes the potential use of a Tolerability of Risk (TOR) framework, originally developed in the United Kingdom and adapted elsewhere, as well as Tolerable Risk Guidelines (TRG). Tolerability of Risk was developed as a framework for reaching decisions with stakeholders that focuses on the most serious risks consistently, efficiently, and transparently. Tolerable Risk Guidelines categorize the nature of risks in ways that can assist in assessing their acceptability or non-acceptability, and in prioritizing actions for reducing risks. (Further information regarding TOR and TRG is available in the summary of Dr. Jean LeGuen’s presentation, in Section 3 of this report, and in his paper, included in Appendix D.)

In March 2008, three Federal agencies – US Army Corps of Engineers (USACE), Department of Interior, Bureau of Reclamation (Reclamation), and Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) convened a workshop entitled “Workshop on Tolerable Risk Evaluation – A step towards developing tolerable risk guidelines for dams and levees”. With the formation of the USACE Levee Safety Program (USACE 2007), attention began to be directed toward adapting the newly developed risk-informed dam safety policies and methods for application to levee systems. The National Committee on Levee Safety (NCLS) authorized by the Levee Safety Act of 2007 published its draft recommendations in January 2009 (NCLS 2009) including Recommendation #5 that Tolerable Risk Guidelines (TRG) be developed for application in risk-informed, flood risk management (FRM) associated with levees. This March 2010 workshop constitutes one step in USACE engaging the flood risk management community to work collaboratively in developing policies, TRG, and methods to further levee safety for the nation.

The workshop purpose was to examine the concepts and principles of tolerability of risk and tolerable risk guidelines and explore their application to, and use in, managing life, economic, and environmental risk associated with levee systems. The workshop scope encompassed national and international approaches to flood risk management, tolerability of risk, and tolerable risk guidelines as they would apply to the USACE levee safety program. The workshop was comprised of three parts: introductory plenary presentations that set a common base and vocabulary for subsequent discussions; three facilitated break-out sessions that deliberated on questions prepared in advance; and concluding panels and plenary sessions that would capture the sense of the participants in what was learned and how to proceed. Invited participants numbering about sixty were from USACE, FEMA, other Federal agencies, professional societies, NGO’s, and from The Netherlands, United Kingdom, Japan, and Spain.

Keywords

levees, risk assessment